
Every Thought Captive Home
Subscribe to ETC
Technology
Volume 5 - Issue 1 (Jan/Feb 2001)
The Vision
Here's Mud in Your Eye
Family Circle
What Hath God Wrought?
Ekklesia
Welcome to the Machine
Rightly Dividing
Saving Labor Devices
Tending Your Garden
A Well-Oiled Machine?
Culture Matters
Already Gone
Practicum
A Technological Dependence Testing Technique
Open Letter
Dogging the Wag
Leviathan
Tools of Dominion
Apologia
Changes
Hit and Run
Re:Views
Unless otherwise noted, all content is Copyright © 2008 Highlands Study Center
|
Squeezing the Clockwork Orange
Technopoly, by Neil Postman
Reviewed by R.C. Sproul Jr.
One of the mega-trends of the end of the twentieth century (and which will,
I'm sure, continue in the new century) has been a spate of works in which the
author is trying to figure out who we in the west are. Some of these cultural
snapshots come from the bulls, with people like George Gilder promising a gigabyte
in every pot, and Alvin Toffler rejoicing that we'll surf the third wave all
the way to the bank. Others have been less sanguine. Jaques Ellul took an early
bear position when he wrote The Technological Society back in the 1970's.
Wendell Berry was a cranky bear in the woods, doing what bears do best, all
over the happy promises of the technophiles in Another Turn of the Crank.
And then the postman rang a third time, with Neil Postman's Technopoly.
Postman's Amusing Ourselves to Death is on my top ten list of the books
which have most influenced me. It highlights how our media affect our message,
arguing that a culture moving from a word based form of communication to an
image based form is waltzing toward the gallows. He argues that we soon will
no longer be able to argue, but will instead only be able to emote, to make
faces at each other. In Technopoly, the lens backs up a bit as he looks
at how the whole technological complex, not just our media, has come to shape
the western mind.
As with your happy editors, Postman is not writing a jeremiad against the combustion
engine, nor would he call the police if he caught you with a Palm Pilot. His
approach is a little more sophisticated than the Luddites, who destroyed machines,
instead of domesticating them. Instead he helps the reader to see many of the
insidious assumptions that undergird our relationship with our machines, and
in turn, how those assumptions influence how we see our relationships with each
other. He gives us one page after page, picture after picture of how technology
has been the engine that drives the habits of our hearts.
It is through our minds and hearts that our machines, our slaves, have revolted
and turned on us. Even the notion that, "resistance is futile," that
we will finally be absorbed, that progress is inevitable (and never asking us
what we mean by "progress") is a function of how machines affect our
thinking. Because we have been programmed by machines, we think we have been
programmed by machines. The good news, however, is that we are free, whether
we know it or not. We do not need to think the thoughts of technology, sometimes
called, "the god who limps' after it." We can think the thoughts of
the one, true God.
Postman is not a Christian. But like so many of the unbelieving writers who
challenge my thinking, he is a man who not only bears God's image, but sees
the image of God in all men. God has been gracious to Postman in giving him
insight, and gracious to us in giving us Postman. As with most of the books
we review here, this one comes with a strong commendation. And while you're
at it, go ahead and read some Ellul and some Berry. Go ahead and use a lamp.
We won't tell anyone.
Other Worlds, Cyber and Domestic
The Edges of the Earth, by Richard Leo
Reviewed by Laurence Windham
I think I bought this book for $2 off a discount table in one of those mega-bookstores
that serve espresso. Edges of the Earth is Richard Leo's account of his
Alaskan homesteading experience. Motivated by the desire to be freed from the
superficial and find some meaning in life, Leo leaves the corporate environment
of New York City with his fiancee, and attempts to construct a new life in the
wilderness. As the reader, you embark with them in their quest for a life that
is fulfilling, enduring with them the Herculean task of living independently
from the umbilical cord of civilization. This is not easily done, as the author,
as well as the reader finds out.
One of the best facets of the book is Leo's commentary on how fragile society
is held together. Watching from a relative's balcony, he witnesses the constant
arrival of semi-trucks bringing food, medicine, and, well, everything into the
city. He muses about what might happen in the city if the freight stopped arriving.
The conclusion frightens him. And this was written well before the Y2K anxiety.
Toward the end of the book his fiance, Melissa, becomes a Christian and leaves
the bohemian because of her new convictions. Surprisingly, the author relates
this event evenhandedly. This isn't a "Christian" book, but the subject
matter should be an encouragement for us all to not be so dependent on Wal-Mart.
mybrainhurts, a website by Russ Young
Reviewed by Laurence Windham
For all you websurfers out there who have gotten bored with the lack of originality
in cyberspace, I suggest you take a look at Russ Young's web page (home.earthlink.net/~mybrainhurts).
Russ has created a site that serves as his virtual soap box, journal, travel
log, and creative outlet. You will find book and movie reviews, sharp-witted
commentary on current issues, poetry, essays, and interesting stories. All of
which springs from a Reformed perspective.
The manner in which Russ serves up the content posted on his site reminds me
of the character, "Chris in the Morning" from the greatest of all
television shows, Northern Exposure. Like listening to "Chris,"
you get the feeling that Russ would be the kind of guy you would like to hang
out with. He appears to be part philosopher, part poet and a little bit, black
lab. (By the way, for you available ladies out there, Russ is single.) His site
is skillfully constructed with hyper links that wisk you away to other arenas
of thought and ideas which makes pursuing mybrainhurts fun as well as provoking.
Yeah, it's a great site, but not one that I personally would want. No, not me.
I'm not jealous. Nope. Not at all. Really!
|